Living Together: The Fascinating World of Symbiosis

For years, my passion for nature and wildlife has inspired me to capture thousands of images that reveal the remarkable realities of the natural world. From simple biological processes to complex behaviors, each image offers a glimpse into the lives of living organisms and the adaptations that allow them to survive in their environments. From the specialized beaks of hummingbirds, shaped through co-evolution to match the pollination needs of their nectar-producing plants, to extraordinary examples of symbiosis between insects and fungi, nature offers a treasure trove of fascinating discoveries for those willing to look closer and explore further.

One of my favorite subjects to document is the remarkable variety of symbiotic relationships found in the wild. Symbiosis refers to a close biological interaction between two different species. These relationships can be short-term or long-lasting, depending on the species involved and the nature of their interaction. In mutualism, both species benefit. In commensalism, one species benefits while the other is neither helped nor harmed. In parasitism, one species benefits at the expense of the other, causing harm to its host.

These relationships can also be classified as obligate or facultative. In an obligate relationship, at least one organism depends on the other for survival or essential biological functions, making the association necessary for its continued existence. Lichens provide a fascinating example of this partnership: a fungus lives in association with a photosynthetic partner, usually an alga or cyanobacterium. The photosynthetic partner produces nutrients, while the fungus provides structure, protection, and access to water and minerals. Although each partner contributes essential benefits, their degree of dependence varies among species.

In contrast, facultative relationships are optional, meaning the organisms can survive independently of one another. A good example is the relationship between fruiting trees and birds. Birds benefit by feeding on the fruit, while the tree may benefit when birds disperse its seeds to new locations. Although this interaction can be advantageous to both, neither organism necessarily depends on the other for survival.

These intricate connections reveal just how interconnected life can be. By documenting them through photography, we can better appreciate the extraordinary strategies organisms have evolved to survive, reproduce, and thrive in an ever-changing natural world.

Commensalism

In this type of relationship only one species benefits while the other is unharmed. In the Galapagos Islands, it can be seen in the Galapagos dove’s choice for nesting substrate. The doves tend to nest in the Opuntia cactus as it provides shelter and protection from predators. Another great example not far from home is the resurrection fern. The fern attaches itself to oak trees where it obtains nutrients through the algal growth on the bark and other nutrients are delivered by the rain and air currents.

Mutualism

Mutualism provides some of the most striking behaviors between species. One of my favorites is the leaf-cutter ants growing a species of fungus that only occurs inside their nests. The ant brings leaves to the nest where they are ground up and inoculated with the fungus. This fungus is the only source of food for the colony, making this an obligate relationship. The fungus will not survive without the ants, and vice versa.  Then you have even more complex relationships like in the case of the yellow-billed hornbill and the dwarf mongoose.  In this case, both organisms look forward to their joint forces. The mongoose digs out its food from the ground and in the process exposes food for the hornbill. The hornbill provides an additional level of safety against predators that is beyond what the mongooses can do on their own. Both species are prone to predation by hawks, so both have developed their own guarding system.  They can warn each other of the presence of a predator, with the bird being the most sensitive and selective. The hornbill will alert of any predator, but ignore those species that do not predate on mongooses. This allows the mongooses an extra level of comfort and reduces their alertness levels.  The more birds present, the less they have to worry. Since the mongooses have their own guarding system, a single bird foraging alongside a large group of mongooses will benefit from their alarms too. Additionally, the hornbills will announce to the mongooses when it’s safe to forage.  The birds will perch near the termite mounds used by the mongooses, then fly to the foraging field and announce the start of the foraging. At this point, the safe conditions will prompt the mongooses to exit the termite mounds and start foraging.

Another great example comes from the lava lizards and marine iguanas of the Galapagos Islands. Marine iguanas get annoyed by flies as they bask on the shores. Being vegetarians, the marine iguana has no taste for flies; instead, the lava lizard takes advantage of the fly buffet and the iguana gets some relief from the pesky insects.

 

Parasitism

In this symbiotic relationship, only one species benefits and the other is harmed or even killed.  Bot flies in tropical areas lay their eggs under the skin of young bird chicks.  The larva develops inside the chick and feeds on blood and tissue, eventually causing the chick to die. Parasitism is most commonly found inside the body, like tapeworms in humans or heartworms in dogs and cats.  Another great example is the braconid wasp which lays its eggs inside a hornworm and the larvae feed on the caterpillar. When they are ready to pupate, the larvae chew their way out of the caterpillar and spin a silk cocoon on its exoskeleton.

Capturing all these natural events can be challenging but rewarding at the same time. The next time you take your camera outdoors, be ready to capture these important moments as these are the kind of images that tell a story about the reality of nature.

Best of 2024

BEST OF 2024

Here are some of my favorites of 2024 from locations including Pennsylvania,  Galapagos Islands, Puerto Rico and Costa Rica.

Chasing Waterfalls

Marshalls Falls, PA.
Gozalandia, PR.
Twin Falls, Costa Rica.
Cataratas del Toro, Costa Rica.

The old saying, “Don’t go chasing waterfalls,” doesn’t apply to me. Traditionally, it serves as a metaphorical warning against pursuing something alluring but potentially harmful or deceptive. While the saying makes sense metaphorically, my reality as a traveling photographer is quite the opposite—I actively seek out waterfalls to capture their beauty.

For one, waterfalls are inherently captivating and visually striking. They showcase the raw power of nature while simultaneously evoking a sense of peace and tranquility. Additionally, the mist generated by cascading water creates a unique environment that nurtures diverse plant and animal life, enhancing the surrounding landscape and making it even more enchanting.

For every new destination I plan to visit, I dedicate countless hours to researching the local wildlife, national parks, and the presence of waterfalls along the route. This approach ensures that I can capture at least one or two stunning waterfall images, no matter where I go. Pre-trip research helps me identify the best viewpoints and optimal times of day for photography.

Waterfalls are relatively straightforward to photograph under the right lighting conditions. Ideally, a cloudy day works best, as it allows for longer exposures and prevents overly bright highlights. Shooting early in the morning, when the waterfall is still in shade, is also a great option, especially if the sky isn’t part of the composition. However, with modern technology, I can photograph waterfalls in almost any lighting condition—even using a fast shutter speed—while still achieving the “silky” water effect characteristic of flowing water.

To capture the desired “silky” water effect, it’s ideal to use a tripod and set your camera’s shutter speed to 1/8 second or slower. However, this isn’t always feasible, especially in bright conditions where too much light makes it impossible to shoot that slow, even at the lowest ISO. In such cases, the traditional solution is to use a Neutral Density (ND) filter, which reduces the light entering the camera and allows for slower shutter speeds.

Modern techniques now provide an alternative to using ND filters for achieving the same silky effect in waterfall photography. By employing faster shutter speeds, such as 1/30 second or faster, you can create a smooth water appearance without the need for additional gear. This method also supports handheld shooting, offering greater convenience and flexibility.

This effective technique for capturing silky water in bright conditions involves taking multiple images in quick succession and blending them in Photoshop. Each shot captures the moving water differently, allowing you to create a stack of images. By aligning them, converting them to a Smart Object, and using Photoshop’s Stack Mode to blend, you can produce a seamless final image. This process combines the exposures while maintaining consistent lighting and detail.

Below, you’ll find a tutorial explaining this technique step by step, enabling you to create silky water effects in any lighting condition. So, on your next trip, be sure to explore waterfall photography opportunities. Our workshop participants always enjoy the refreshing change of pace after days of photographing birds and wildlife.

Video Tutorial

Loving Nature To Death

Loving Nature to Death

More than 30 vehicles were encroaching on a leopard that was hiding in the bushes.

I was about fifteen years old when I was given a camera with which to explore the world. What began as a way to keep me out of trouble became my way to make a living. For years, I have worked as a commercial photographer shooting product advertising, food, architecture, events and even editorial. But my true passion is for the critters living around me. Later  in life, armed with enough knowledge about the natural world, I embarked on a long journey to document wildlife and educate people about the importance of all living things.  My photography became a medium to reach people and teach them something they didn’t know. This journey has taken me to some of the most amazing places in the world.  From hotspots of biodiversity in the Amazon and Central America, to the ever-changing Galapagos and the megafauna of Africa, each has provided me with multiple opportunities to understand life and the importance of each individual and its impact on the ecosystems they live in. That includes animals like us, humans.

 

Over the years I have seen many more people exploring the outdoors, kayaking, boating, camping and photographing wildlife. Some with very positive results; others, not so much.  Nature photography has become one of the most common outdoor hobbies, bringing people closer to nature. But sometimes these encounters may have detrimental effects on the wildlife we love so much.

 

As a naturalist and photography instructor, I try to teach the ethics of nature photography to my students in an effort to create nature-conscious individuals. Learning when your actions affect your subject or others in the ecosystem is very important. I have learned from my own mistakes.  There was a time in my life where documenting birds nesting was a priority, until I noticed the effect this could have on nesting birds. Having witnessed many nesting birds fail due to increased visitation from photographers and nature lovers made me realize the impacts are no different than any other anthropogenic causes. In our quest to get the best image possible, we fail to recognize the level of impact we imposed on our subjects. Recently, during the Covid-19 pandemic, the effect of our love for nature and the outdoors was seen across our national parks, where masses of people went in search of relief after lockdown.  The parks were littered with garbage and animal-human conflicts were on the rise. How can we love something so much to the point of hurting it? The answer may lie in our own selfishness. Take for example the case of a man that took a selfie too close to a large alligator.  Without hesitation, the photo is posted on social media and many more join the craze.  A few weeks later, the famed alligator was deemed too friendly and was removed from the reserve.  Its final destination was unknown, but most people assumed it was euthanized. The moral of the story is that without knowing, the selfishness of these individuals and their unethical behavior caused the loss of one famous alligator. 

 

Few years ago the strange sighting of a Snowy Owl on the beaches of Jacksonville drew the attention of many birders and photographers that tried their chances at seeing or photographing this northern species.  People from all over Florida were trampling the vegetation along the sand dunes, and their mere presence made the owl a bit antsy.  The constant chase prevented the owl from resting and hunting properly to the point that the owl died.  My question then, is do those people really care about the owl, or did they care more about their own selfishness of getting the shot. 

 

The stories of unethical encounters with wildlife are more common that many of us want to admit. One time, while walking a preserve, I came across an individual placing his arm inside a gopher tortoise burrow in hopes of getting the tortoise out for a photo opportunity. Besides advising him on the illegality of his actions, I went into explaining the danger he was exposing himself to. It’s not unusual to find rattlesnakes living in the gopher tortoise burrows. While my actions were passive, my only hope was for him to learn about the big mistake he had just made.  You may have heard about a few cases of wild animals that have been removed from the environment because of people feeding them, or treating them as pets, etc. Sometimes we think we are doing them a favor by providing them water or food, when in reality we are just sentencing them to death. That’s the reason the signs read “A fed bear is a dead bear.” I guess that applies to gators, too. But while this expression may apply to certain situations, like campgrounds and parks, we can’t deny that feeding may be positive in a different situation. Take, for example, the scheduled feeding of California condors in locations where the birds were re-introduced. But these are specific situations that are carefully monitored for the benefit of the species, not for the benefit of the photographer.

More recently I have witnessed how our love for wildlife and getting the perfect shot may be affecting the migration of thousands of ungulates in Africa.  While visiting the Mara River in Kenya to document the Great Wildebeest Migration, I was appalled to see how many tour operators will park their vehicles right on the path of the migrating wildebeest to give their clients the ultimate view.  It was bad enough to prevent the wildebeest from crossing the river. Instead of allowing enough room for them to cut across, the vehicles on the opposite side of the river bank acted as a concrete wall preventing the animals from even attempting the crossing. This is the largest land migration on earth with more than 2 million animals crossing the Mara every year as they move from Tanzania to Kenya. I also learned about an apparent practice in Tanzania to set fires to delay the migration of the wildebeest in an effort to keep the business in the country. While Tanzania denies the practice, many tour operators in Kenya continue to blame Tanzania for the stalled migrations.

 

A few days later, we encountered a leopard that was surrounded by nearly 40 safari vehicles loaded with tourists with cellphones in hand.  The vehicles were inching against each other in hopes to get a clear view of the shaken cat. The story later repeated itself, this time with a lonely cheetah. Vehicles circled the exhausted animal, with the insensible occupants taking pictures with their phones at close distance. Both experiences were too much for me to bear and I asked our drivers to leave the area immediately. My conscience was telling me: “the shot is not more important than the welfare of the subject.” But for the tour operators, putting their clients in the best spot usually means more money in the form of tips. A hard habit to break when they need the money.

 

So, what can be done to avoid this type of wildlife encroachment? Perhaps the answer lies in each one of us and how we communicate with the people near us about the dangers that our actions pose to wildlife. National parks and preserves need to teach their operators about safe viewing distances, and proper wildlife-watching etiquette.  We need to make it illegal to approach the wildlife, and denounce those who commit the crime. We can never allow money to dictate our actions and we must always work for the safety of our wild animals and natural resources. At the end, we won’t have anything to photograph when it’s all gone. Do your part and learn what is too close or too much.

 

Visitors taking selfies with a white-faced capuchin on their shoulders at Manuel Antonio National Park, Costa Rica.
A cheetah poses for the thrilled visitors as they snap a group shot. Masai Mara , Kenya.
Sometimes we get closer than we need, just for the thrill, or to claim we were that close.
Several safari vehicles blocking the path used by the wildebeest to cross the Mara River.

A Unique Way To School

Traveling through Central and South America, it’s hard to miss kids walking to school. Some walk for miles even before the sun rises to make sure they arrive on time. In most of these countries, schools have separate morning and afternoon sessions in order to accommodate all the grade levels on limited resources that include small buildings, no budget to provide lunch and the lack of teachers. In the afternoon, the younger kids are going back home while the older students come to session.  In remote areas the daily migration is even more common. School buses are limited or non-existent, so it’s not unusual to see seven year-old kids walking long ways along the roads or picking up a ride on public transportation.

But nothing more challenging than going to school by water. Yes, in many remote areas of Panama, I have encountered kids traveling by water in dugout canoes. This time I was in the southern range of the Bocas del Toro archipelago. For a moment you feel in another world as you are surrounded by emerald waters hugged by mangroves tall enough to touch the sky. As idyllic as it sounds it is a dangerous risk that many kids take on a daily basis.  I can only assume that classes are dismissed if bad weather approaches, but then…how would they know when far from the reach of technology? For days I lived without the cellphone lifeline I’m so used to. I was so far away from civilization that any accident could have been devastating and venomous snakes are commonly seen along the forest floor here. The waters are also patrolled by sharks. In fact, I glanced at a hammerhead just a few minutes before snapping some pictures of three kids paddling their ancient dugout canoe to school. But despite all the dangers, students and teachers make the treacherous trip from and back to school.

But the students are not the only ones on a challenging trek. One day, while driving on the main land, I came across a teacher that was in need of a ride home. She teaches at a remote school that requires a one hour hike each way through a dirt road crossing three bridgeless rivers and up to two hours by bus to the city where she lives. Every day she makes this journey for the kids in this rural community of Panama composed mainly of indigenous people of the Ngöbe-Buglé tribe.

While the purpose of my trip was to document frogs, watching the kids paddling to school was an eye-opening experience that will last a lifetime. The pictures are just there to remind me of the things I take for granted and how easy life is on my corner of the world.